Why Real Transportation Reform Died

Heritage Action has detailed at length what a good transportation policy should look like.  Senator Jim DeMint (R-SC) and Representative Tom Graves (R-GA) have both introduced the Transportation Empowerment Act (S.1164 /H.R.3264), which would begin the process of returning responsibility for transportation back to the states.  It is an excellent piece of legislation and received the support of 30 Senators earlier this year – a remarkably strong foundation.

House Republican leaders were leery of taking that approach, so instead they unveiled a proposal last July that increased state flexibility (as opposed to turning back the decisions entirely) and would have been covered entirely by revenues coming into the federal Highway Trust Fund.  At the very least, it “was a reflection of the mandate sent by the American people in 2010 and the widely touted Ryan Budget.”

Unfortunately, they moved away from that vision, reverting to a more political document that spent far too much.  Last week, a blurb in POLITICO’s Morning Transportation confirmed, yet again, it was “moderate” Republican lawmakers who forced House Republican leadership away from real reforms:

Shuster and Mica told reporters as much of H.R. 7 as they can get through – but one thing that isn’t happening is a change to dedicated transit funding. “We have 25 suburban/urban guys that just aren’t going to go for it,” Shuster said, adding the Senate is filled with urban politicians as well. “It’ll remain the way it is.” Mica said there will be meetings next week to figure out what the top priorities will be – but environmental streamlining is a huge one. 

Although conservatives frequently draw the ire of leadership and many in the press, it has become increasingly clear there is a significant block of so-called moderate Republicans who are stymieing efforts to change how Washington works.  As many conservatives look ahead to 2013, that should be concerning.

Please Share Your Thoughts

One thought on “Why Real Transportation Reform Died

  1. when in the last 2 years “Americas so called Worst Downturn sense 1929” why in the world did the fed gas tax go for Government Pay and not pot holes? the entire gov Pay should be Investagated ,when gov pay has SKYROCKETED past the Payrolltax cut to sometimes TWICE ,near 1/2 the pay provided is exempt from the taxpayers benifits of SS and Medicare Then so to should the public funding of gov benifits and raise gov contribution to pay more and not just in single didgits

    Let states build own roads ,and not some slush fund to just pay higher wages ,states will do far better job and with LESS MONEY ……..many states wanted to raise gas tax but were stopped , …….simpson bowles want another 15 cents for gas tax? for what more pay and this idea to fund or subsidize FAA and airlines , raise the Ticket prices to fund airports

    so stand up for better roads ,States Can Do Better ,call and tell them to TURN BACK the fed gas tax ,ITS THE LAW

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *